Beyond the dominant narratives: Identifying Indigenous and African individuals in Quebec St-Lawrence Valley colonial cemeteries by three-dimensional morphometrical analysis of the temporal bone

In Quebec, written accounts of free or enslaved Indigenous and African individuals during colonial times are few and limited. Three-dimensional geometric morphometric methods applied on 214 temporal bones individuals are used to explore intra-cemetery population variation throughout three centuries (1683–1878), to identify plausible non-European or admixed individuals. First, Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was generated from populations originated from Africa, North-America (Indigenous) and Europe where colonial cemeteries are projected to assess their degree of overlap with the reference groups. Second, Discriminant Function Analysis (DFA) based on typicality probabilities also allowed to assign unknown individuals to the three reference groups. Our results highlighted discrepancy between PCA and DFA. With the PCA, Quebec colonial groups overlap with the Europeans except for three individuals. For the DFA, 64 % (n = 136) were classified as typical to one group and 36 % as atypical (n = 77). Most were European, (82 %; n = 112), followed by those as Indigenous (7 %; n = 10), intermediate between Africans and Indigenous (6 %; n = 8) and Africans (5 %; n = 7). Compared with previous research, one individual from the first Protestant cemeteries of St-Matthew in Quebec could be assessed as plausible African or admixed origin. Two others need further analysis: one from St-Matthew and one from the first Catholic cemetery of Notre-Dame in Montreal. Finally, in response to dominant narratives that focused mainly on Euro-colonists, this research provided for the first time a new snapshot of several colonial population diversity in Quebec, underlining the presence of marginalized groups -especially those of African origin, who are absent from the archaeological reports under study.